You can even distinguish them by design at first sight. 162 likes. The Yoder smokers grills are one of the prominent and most prominent grills in the market. You will be happy with either choice. I still think the trap door assembly on the Yoder for direct flame sear is a better design than the P&S which requires you to move the shield to access the flame after you remove the trap door. ** Other cooking techniques are welcomed for when your cookin' in the kitchen. Yoder grill is designed for heavy use makes it an ideal option for you if you are going to be smoking lots of meat and cooking too. Disaster Relief Dinner: Blackened Filet Mignon (Lotsa Pics @ Lotsa Dialog), Pellet Grill Wont Get Up To Temp. Here we discussed everything in detail about these two reliable companies. The second most crucial component of a pellet smoker is hopper capacity. This is a wood grill, and it makes use of real wood which helps it produce a great smokey flavor you cant help but love. Congrats, fantastic looks great! PELLET GRILLS SHOP NOW SMOKERS SHOP NOW CHARCOAL Congrats, you chose wisely, and WELCOME to the MAK FAMILY! This food appliance is designed to endure a long time and the ownership of the brand values functionality; therefore, it is manufactured of high-quality materials that are resistant to tear as well as wear. But its nothing to be worried about. . Material We have analyzed two of the most famous pellet smokers from both brands and prepared a head-to-head confrontation to let you make an informed buying decision. Yoder smokers are the ideal choice for you if you are going to be grilling a lot. I have seen them in a shop and they feel much more sturdy than Traeger and the like. Awesome, just ordered the 1250 with smoke box! All thanks to their versatility and high-functioning features. Whereas the P&S grill can hold up to 35 pounds of wood pellets, the Yoder one can hold 20 pounds. If theres a Black Friday sale I may just pull the trigger. This grill comes standard with Pitts & Spitts' signature 304 stainless steel lid and work shelf. Safe to assume youll only be smoking/roasting on said unit, with little to no grilling? If you want more cooking space, go for Pitts and Spitts. Talking of the ceramic igniter, its a wonderful add-on for rapid and seamless ignition. But the most distinctive feature of this pellet grill is the opportunity to direct over the flame grilling. Need to add a pellet to the arsenal. Learn more. Similar to the Pitts and Spitts, its also a US-based BBQ product manufacturing company. My one complaint, if it can be labeled a complaint, is that the diffuser with a door was not standard when I bought mine 3+ years ago. You wont find many pellet grill/smokers that come close to it. This pellet grill can be used for commercial purposes and although this is expensive but considering the quality, it is worth going for. The one question that you haven't asked yet: "which would look better in your backyard (on your porch/deck, etc)?". They answered every single question I had and walked me through the setup when I received it. All times are GMT-6. They can reach over 600 degrees of temperature. Click here to read our complete review. I have owned mine for 2 years now, use it constantly, and I personally feel after all this time, that no other company can provide a product as built as well as your smoker is built, nor provide a better smoked product off of its racks, as well as what the Pitts smoker provides!! Please use them. On the other hand, the Yoder grills are surely more heavy-duty, but they are the best for commercial use. I'm interested in this thread but don't have experience with either of these cookers. The Broil King Signet 320 is a modestly priced, 3-burner gas grill that packs a lot of value and power under the hood including dual-tube burners that are able to achieve high, searing temps that rival most comparatively priced gas grills. Rec Tec Vs Grilla A Head To Head Comparison, Old Country Brazos vs Pecos | 11 Features Which Is Better, Oklahoma Joe Longhorn VS Highland | Best BBQ Smoker With Coolest Feature. Both cookers (like all cookers) come with pros/cons. It can even read the pellet burn rates quite efficiently. A comparison between these two grills is necessary if you cant make up your mind. Get a free 30-day trial here. You must log in or register to reply here. Based on what I've read, I believe the P&S has more even temps and for me has a better overall feature set and would be my choice if buying. Thats a nice cooking arsenal! Therefore, they will let you smoke longer. The best thing was the place I got it talking to the dealer. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Besides, all their products are quite easy to clean. So, we can simply say that Pitts and Spitts grills provide more cooking surfaces than Yoder grills. PITTS & SPITTS HAS BEEN A LEGEND IN THE BBQ BUSINESS FOR NEARLY 40 YEARS. the best offset smokers for the money Best Under $2,000 Lang 36" Patio Smoker Check Price Pro: Smoker and grill hybrid Pro: High quality wheels Pro: Diverse temperatures Our winner for the best offset smoker . Fairly enough, they do justify their tagline by making competition-quality smokers and grills since 2007. Now lets take a look at different types of grills and their functionalities manufactured by these two companies. Just a little bit of elbow grease will get the job done. Whereas you may be able to sear better on the Yoder, youre much more likely to battle paint failure on the Yoder. Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 vs Yoder YS 640s Comparison Chart, Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder: Head to Head Comparison. The S series microprocessor is among the most sophisticated controllers in the industry, capable of monitoring and adapting to a variety of input factors in order to maintain a constant temperature. Fire it up, stick in the probes and monitor things from your smart phone. Never heard anything bad about either. So, which brand is best between Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder as a grill manufacturer? I used my Traeger for just about everything and would like to continue that trend with my next purchase. Pitts And Spitts Grills are manufactured from stainless steel materials. The bigger the hopper capacity, the longer burn the grill offers. Choosing a specific type of Yoder grill isnt complicated since they are all built with high-quality material and over the years, old and new customers have continued to show they are happy about their products. . Its among the best bargains for a smoker in the world. That surely adds a great plus to the overall performance of this awesome pellet grill from Pitts and Spitts. There were a few reasons why I went the way that I did: The P&S are completely hand-welded, no spot welding/caulking. The key feature of any grill is functionality. Besides, their feature-loaded performances wont disappoint you. There are several reasons this pellet grill is popular and here are a few to mention-. Yes, I own a MAK and my opinion is biased lol but I cannot recommend them highly enough. As these two pellet grills are of similar features and represent their respective brands, we can easily conclude that the Pitts and Spitts products offer more hopper capacity. But here is an analysis of the special features of the Yoder charcoal grill and their popular pellet grill with stainless steel shelves. Let's look into the temperature control of each brand separately. Authorized Distributor For Pitts and Spitts Smokers and Grills. ["pitmaster-my-membership","login","join-pitmaster","lostpw","reset-password","special-offers","help","nojs","meat-ups","gifts","authaau-alpha","ebooklogin-start","alpha","start"], {"count":0,"link":"/forum/announcements/","debug":""}, Meathead, The Science of Great Barbecue and Grilling, Grills, Smokers, Other Cookers, Outdoor Kitchens, Click here to learn more about benefits to membership. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Traeger Pro 780 vs Ironwood 650 | Want To know Which Grill Is For You? It may not display this or other websites correctly. The Pitts and Spitts grills come with a relatively conventional grill design. The main difference between Pitts and Spitts, and the Yoder grill is the control system. No experience with either but the Pitts and Spitts smokers have always caught my eye. In fact, many of their smoking accessories have won some international prestigious competitions due to their incredible workmanship. The only thing I have heard doing my own research was the Pitts and spitts is meant for smoking not so much grilling. We rarely recommend products we haven't tested and we never recommend products that we don't love. Though both brands offer outstanding temperature control, the Yoder is a bit ahead in this regard. One significant difference between the two pellet grills is the temperature range. However, that wasnt all you needed to choose an efficient grill. Click here to read more about our review process. Its an appliance that has been handcrafted and built-in Texas, and its quite versatile as well. They are hand made in Wichita, KS. Besides, any sort of combination pits or travel smokers enrich their lineups more. Being a wi-fi-controlled grilling accessory, it lets you control the gadget remotely with your cell phone. Meathead's AmazingRibs.com promises to never sell or distribute any info about you individually without your express permission, and we promise not to, ahem, pepper you with email or make you eat spam. The Yoder I feel will be much more suited to that. Do a thorough inspection of the grill every week, Surfaces of the smoker can be washed down using soapy water and rinsed with clean water (Use natural detergent), Make sure the grill is completely cold before scooping out the ashes to be disposed, To control grease build-up, its recommended that you use a citrus-based cleaning solution. YS1500 vs Pitts and SPitts I was on the phone earlier looking to order a YS1500 and the salesman on the other line mentioned that pitts and spits model is quite good and has PID controller and is fully welded. The popularity of their grills has also increased over the years. Unlike most other smokers in this segment, it charges a bit more which is not so budget-friendly. He gave me a fairly detailed comparison and recommended the 700. They now fabricate their own hopper assembly and use what appears to be a Roanoke controller programmed to their specifications. My local dealer carries both. Pitts and spitts grill have also been around for over 30 years which marks its difference from the Yoder grill. The ys640s temp control is not great. The beauty of the Flat Top is the fire table moves up and down and makes control much easier. Product links. Pitts and spitts grills can get as hot as over 600 degrees and the pellet grates happen to be easy to clean as well. There is only 1 pellet grill that has proven itself to sear GREAT and that is fast eddy. Trophlin 3 yr. ago Pitts & Spitts has a direct grilling option and is cheaper than Yoders ($124.99 vs $189.00) Ciecocattivo2 3 yr. ago Fair enough. Isnt that great? It is reasonably priced, especially considering the high quality of the grills accessories. Based on different cooking temperatures, Yoder grills and smokers can run up to 12 hours. Whether you feel like grilling briskets, pork butts, turkeys, or chicken, the 1070 sq. Now the largest membership-based BBQ and grilling community in the world, the Pitmaster Club is sure to step up your outdoor cooking game. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Whereas the Pitts & Spitts grills are excellent for use in the home, they are also best suited for business use. If we compare the Maverick 1250 and Yoder YS 640s, we see that the P&S smoker offers more cooking area. Yoder Smokers is a reliable grills and smoker accessories supplier company. If grilling were not so important to me, hands down Id take the Pitts. SmokingMeatForums.com is a community of barbecue and outdoor cooking enthusiasts dedicated to smoking meat. Constructed with high-quality components. REC TEC actually performs better in this category than Traeger does because its grills have a temperature range of between . Every type of grill comes with its manual and tips generally and this has no exception either. If I were going to go away from Yoder, it would be a Mak or Memphis, not saying they are better or worse, because I really don't know, but they have been in the pellet game for a long time, and make good cookers. I've narrowed down my choice to either the P&S 850 or the Yoder 640. It comes packed with additional features like meat hooks, a grease drain and a convenient ash removal tray that makes clean up easier. Click here to read more about our review process. Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250 w/ smokebox Fast Eddy's PG1000 I'm cooking for 2-4 people most of the time. I'll personally never own anything but Yoder. Since 1983, the wonderfully named Pitts & Spitts has been making high-quality smokers in Houston, Texas. WHEN WE WENT SHOPPING FOR A LOG PIT A FEW YEARS AGO, OUR CHOICE WAS ULTIMATELY THE PITTS & SPITTS ULTIMATE SMOKER, A GENUINE GEM. Please contact us for So Cal Delivery options. The craftsmanship and durability of the product have made it stand out for years. Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 Pellet Grill 3 Reviews $2,399.99 Availability in store at TheBBQHQ Simi Valley: In stock From $216.62/mo with View sample plans Configuration: Quantity Add to cart Add to Wishlist 6 Share this: In-Store Pick Up Only! Because of their remarkable degree of craftsmanship, Pitts & Spitts goods outperform the competitors. Affordability RT-590 grill is priced at around $1200, whereas it can also be bought from the official website of Rec Tec at $900 with free shipping. Something that I feel is important to know and consider. Thats why the Pitts and Spitts win the race here by offering an extensive grilling surface. If direct grill is paramount, look at the Fast Eddy line. Im fully aware of the rust concerns on the Yoder. I have a GMG and PB and both died on me in the last month so wanting to step up in the world. *ON TOPIC ONLY* QUALITY ON TOPIC discussion of Backyard BBQ, grilling, equipment and outdoor cookin' . Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. in that time, pitts & spitts has been mixing texas tradition with new world techniques to consistently produce the best-looking, best-cooking smokers & grills. I know people have asked the question before about the PID and the general response has been that the yoder firmware is better. You get what you pay for. Also, you need to fix the felt strip on the lid after a while as it falls off. Pitts And Spitts vs Yoder Grills Comparison (2022), Pitts And Spitts vs Yoder Grill Comparison (Updated), Tips And Manual For Using Your Pitts And Spitts Grill, [How to Fix] Gas Grill Gets Too Hot On Low Setting, How To Get Crispy Chicken Skin On A Pellet Grill, How Long to Rest Pork Butt After Grilling, Can You Use Gasoline to Start A Grill? Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder - The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS. The controlling system is the crucial distinction between Pitts and Spitts, as well as the Yoder grill. I would second the Pitts & Spitts recommendation. Cooking capacity is another point that differs between Pitts and Spitts grills and Yoder grills. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. Great direct drill, excellent smoker, just limited in smoking capacity. > Discussion Area > Q-talk Pitts and Spitts vs. Yoder (pellet) Register FAQ Calendar Mark Forums Read Notices Welcome to BBQ Brethren's Forums. On the contrary, a Yoder wood pellet grill seals the deal by offering more long-lasting construction and better temperature control. Yoder cons: - Higher end models such as the YS640 Elite (upwards of $2000) and the Yoder 640 (upwards of $1000) might be out of some people's budgets. Due to the quality and accessories that come with this grill, you must have a clear manual on how to operate it and tips that can help make better use of it as well. Hi all, Ive been planning to purchase a YS640 for quite some time but have recently came across the Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 and it seems to be a really well built smoker. JavaScript is disabled. To understand this point, you should consider comparing two products from these two brands. Another great advantage of their grilling gadgets is that you can smoke, roast, sear, or BBQ according to your needs. Pitts and Spitts grills can reach temperatures of over 600 degrees, and the pellet grates are very simple to clean. Being a member of both groups on Facebook, I noticed that pretty much all of the posts on the P&S group were of people enjoying everything about it. Those are three great choices and you can't go wrong with any of them. There are now 3 things that test a marriage. Deciding between a Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder grill isnt rugged because they both provide the same value but at different pricing and with distinct capabilities. This is just my opinion, but I think it is the opinion of many. As a reputed and reliable grills accessories manufacturer, Pitts and Spitts manufacture high-quality grills in the market. Yoder grills are made from chrome-plated steel and powder-coated steel with a single layer lid. Keeping these minor issues aside, this is actually a terrific grill for pellet grill lovers. These three brands have reputation for providing high-quality cooking appliances however Yoder grill is considered more expensive. Being you are looking at new pellet grills, is the the Rec Tec not working out for you? The best of the best IMO. If budget is an issue, we dont recommend the Yoder one as it is high-priced and not really affordable. When I got it I was amazed that the quality of workmanship/design was the same high quality of my 1250. Here we see that the Maverick 1250 from P&S beats the Yoder 640s having a way bigger hopper capacity. Whereas the P&S grill can hold up to 35 pounds of wood pellets, the Yoder one can hold 20 pounds. They make everything from backyard smokers to portable kitchens you need a fifth-wheel to haul. To set you up for ultimate success, we also offer high quality wood pellets, grill grates, and a local Texas spice line. To clear all the points more deeply, well compare several individual products from these two manufacturers. I reached out to a guy who had posted cooks on YouTube using both the Pitts and the RT 700 and asked him for his opinion. The SmokeFire excitement didn't last long. This grill manufacturer prioritizes quality over quantity, which is why these grills are so impressive. Read on for the full comparison and understanding of these two popular grills. I was seriously considering a Yoder or P&S and then switched gears to the drum. Pitts and Spitts was a HUGE name around Houston back in the 80's. It is more expensive than many barbecue grills as well as Yoder smokers within the category, especially from top manufacturers like Pit Boss or even Traeger, yet it provides excellent value. Although both are world-famous grill manufacturers, like all other pellet pits, they too have their own amenities and drawbacks. Pitts & Spitts Copyright 2022 | Site by Batch Creative. Anyone have experience with both and input on them? Privacy Policy. Experience the countless benefits from monthly giveaways, to free products, to exclusive content, and more by signing up for a 30-day free trial below! But that naturally costs a fortune whereas the carbon steel model is more than okay to last quite long. He said a Yoder fluctuates just like the GMG so I choose the P&S. On the other hand, P&S products are also decent in terms of longevity. In terms of producing the most reliable pellet pits, Pitts and Spitts is a legendary name in the industry. Pellet Smoker Cook-Off | Yoder vs Weber vs GMG vs Pitts & Spitts 3 Year Pellet Grill Review | Pitts & Spitts Pellet Grill Review I Ate the Best Barbecue in the World | Mad Scientist. I'm looking for a good mix between grilling and smoking. On the Pitts you can have a small direct flame zone, but the opening is offset a bit cutting back on the intensity of the searing action. Uses several variables and distributes heat evenly. It is said that Yoder smokers are built to last. Great people to deal with and the product is built like the proverbial tank at 335# and adds lots of smokey goodness to whatever I cook HTH YMMV, I had a yoder 640 and it works well. It can easily do 8-9lb pork butts for example. Dad, mom and son operation. This company has an extended period of experience in this platform. SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases. the-YS480s competition pellet grill from Yoder Smokers and MAVERICK 1250 WOOD PELLET GRILL from Pitts and Spitts are the very same grill. Pitt is heavier built, the bottom grate pulls out so it's easier to get the cap off the drip pan to sear. Often, but not always, if you purchase a product after clicking a link on our site we get a finder's fee. On the other hand, the Yoder grills come with steel construction. One of the most popular products from this range is the Maverick 1250. As Aaron says, if you are lookin' it ain't cookin'. All things being equal, Id pick one over Yoder. On the other hand, the Yoder grills come with steel construction. They are one of the best American grill manufacturers and happen to be the only wood pellet smoker maker in Texas. On the other hand, the Yoder grills are full-steel grills with more reliable construction. If you cant decide between these two grills, youll need to compare them. I had to sell mine when we went full time RV. The Yoder pellet grill has a warranty of 10 years which is one of its most amazing features. Anyone have any experience with both of these? The smaller cooking area was my only real concern. He asked me what I didn't like about the GMG other than being made overseas..temp fluctuations. You guys provide one HELL of a SUPERB smoker! Yoder YS640 vs Pitts and Spitts 850 Curious what peoples thoughts are on the yoder vs p&s. I see yoder had lots of paints issues but just spoke to them and they said they've improved their painting process. Each grate only has half a rail to slide on. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Cookie Notice Their widespread product range takes care of all your smoking, grilling, barbecuing, and braising needs. If you are going to grill a lot, they are, indeed, matchless to last longer than any average smoker or grill. I can't speak to the MAK other than I have only read positive feedback in all the forums and FB about them. And the Yoder YS 640s is backed by a 10-years warranty on the grill body, 3 years on the control system, and 3 years on the igniter. So, choose your grill wisely according to the feature you value the most. These three brands have reputation for providing high-quality cooking appliances however Yoder grill is considered more expensive. If you are interested in a Pitts & Spitts Pellet Grill and have any questions you can contact: +1 (832)-214-8590 for more information. Yoder brands are the most suitable frequent BBQ competitions as each grill has an increment of five degrees. (Better Alternatives). 327 74K views 5 years ago I received some questions about why I chose the Pitts and Spitts New Pellet Grill vs the Yoder YS 640. I've had food off my DB, a Yoder 640 and a Traeger. Resultantly, they infuse amazing smoky smack into the food. Yoder, which was founded in 2007, focuses on producing competition-quality smokers. Considering the overall quality and performance, Yoder grills are available at a fair price. Yoder grills provide superior performance. If you went to the Houston Rodeo cookoff in the 80's, it was endless rows of Pitts and Spitts. The Fireboard is industry leading and combined with the 20 lbs hopper makes a smoke pretty effortless. Never seen a P&P but from what I've seen they look like an excellent cooker. Click here to read more and to purchase. Yoder is actually cheaper if you compare stainless steel models. Comparatively, the YS640 temperature ranges from 150 to 600 degrees. Can You Cook Beef Brisket In An Air Fryer? Although they started their journey much later than Pitts and Spitts, currently, they are ruling as one of the most well-known smokers and grill manufacturers. The design of these two companies grills is one of the notable things that set them apart from each other. According to reviews, this is regarded as a genuine ultimate smoker with easy-to-operate functions. Here we are with a direct comparison between Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 vs Yoder YS 640 to decide on the best pellet grill. Be the first to rate this post. Thanks! Pits by JJ is dedicated to building quality custom-made barbecue pits for the individual's. Upgraded 9-hole burnpot; creates a more. However, there are a few factors that could be improved. I also was looking at Pitts and Spitts but the inability to actually see one in person really affected my decision. The main difference between Pitts and Spitts, and the Yoder grill is the control system. The Yoder pellet grill is made in the US and has won so many awards as a reliable grill. The Maverick 1250 offers 10 years warranty for the barrel, 3 years for the PID controller, and 1 year for other parts.